Public/private
In high school, I had a boyfriend who was considered one of the funniest, most vivacious people in the school. He was an actor and a comedian and extremely talented at it--the closest thing we had in our small suburban New Jersey town to a Monty Python crew member. People loved him. We started dating and he turned out to be one of the saddest, most depressed people I'd ever met, now or since. No one ever would have guessed this; no one.
There was another guy I was friends with with once who told me that though not appearing so on the exterior, he was extraordinarily romantic and when when he had feelings for a woman he was prone to showering her with compliments and sweet loving statements during sex in a way that could sometimes even be almost over the top. I eventually went out with this guy, and while he was verbal during our sex sessions in the typical dirty talk/moaning kind of way, I can't remember one sweet romantic pronouncement ever being made out loud during sex, let alone many.
I once dated a guy who said he had a huge...
Oh wait, that one was true. Heh, nevermind.
Sorry, just felt the need for a little levity.
Anyway, I'm not sure what made me start writing about this exactly. I guess it's related to the fact that recently I saw an old boyfriend interacting with another woman and it made me think silently to her, I know something you don't know; you have no idea what you're in for. And then I thought, well, then again, he might not know what she's in for, either, because he'd have to be conscious of some of the ways he is; and I'm not sure he is.
And that got me thinking about the public face and private face we have. And it made me think whether sometimes we're even conscious others who are intimate with us (whether romantically or as friends, whatever) see two different faces. Do most people believe their own public stories about themselves? Or even, as in the case of my second boyfriend anecdote up there, if they are aware that they have a public and private self (as I think many people are aware) do most people believe the public stories they tell about their private selves; and are they aware that their private selves are sometimes different than their own perceptions of them? Do most people have a skewed view of their own persona, whether public or private or both? Do most people not even have both--are most people more or less the same in both realms, and I'm just assuming most people have two different personas because I always used to?
Do most people not even define their own persona at all to others? Is the "what I'm like" story just more common to the types of self-analytical people I've hung out with, but the rest of the world is not so navel gazing? Do most people not have a "what I'm like" story they use to define themselves?
It's just interesting. I guess it's silly to posit what "most people" are like; there is no baseline for these things. But as someone who's struggling to work through all the layers of fake definition I've piled on; who wants to strip it down and be the same person, the real person, the aware and genuine person wherever I am, it makes me think about whether even thinking about "who I am" at all will actually help me get to "who I am." Or will it KEEP me from being that person?
I don't know. But somehow this whole being different people in public and private, and different people in story and in reality....something about that feels like something I don't want anymore. Maybe I don't want any stories anymore period. Not for myself, and not anyone else who tells them about themselves.
I mean, I see my friends who are parents doing this about their kids all the time: "this one is like this," "the other one is like that." I wonder if we absorb these self-stories and the tendency to create them so early on that it just feels like a normal, necessary part of creating identity.
But maybe identity doesn't have anything to do with definition or delineation at all.
Maybe it's not "this is who I am" or "this is how I am" and it's only "I am." Maybe that's all I or anyone really needs.
---
photo credit: Public private by isadub
